Amex Blue Cash Preferred pays 6% cash back at U.S. supermarkets, but only on the first $6,000 in purchases a year, then 1%. The Robinhood Gold Card pays 3% on everything with no cap, for a $50 annual Gold membership. The 6% headline is worth at most $180 more than a flat 3% card, and that ceiling is what makes this comparison close.

Most people compare the 6% to the 3% and stop. The cap decides it, and the cap is small enough that one line item on the Amex side can flip the whole answer.

The Cap Nobody Runs the Math On

Six percent on $6,000 is $360. Three percent on the same $6,000 is $180. The difference is $180 a year, and that is the maximum the 6% rate can ever beat a flat 3% rate on groceries, no matter how much you spend at the store.

Spend $12,000 at supermarkets and the Amex earns $360 on the first $6,000 plus $60 on the second at 1%, for $420. The Gold Card earns $360. The gap narrows to $60, because every dollar past the cap earns 1%.

The 6% is a $180 coupon, not a rate.

The Two Rate Cards

Robinhood Gold CardAmex Blue Cash Preferred
U.S. supermarkets3%6% on first $6,000/yr, then 1%
Select U.S. streaming3%6%
Transit3%3%
U.S. gas stations3%3%
Everything else3%1%
Annual fee$0 card, $50/yr Gold required$0 first year, then $95
Cap on rewardsNone$6,000 on the 6% grocery tier
RedemptionRobinhood brokerage, 1 cent per pointStatement credit, Amex HYSA, or Amazon checkout
Foreign transaction fee3%2.7%

The Amex wins three categories and loses one, and the one it loses is the largest category in most budgets. That is why the totals come out closer than the rate table suggests.

Three Households, Three Answers

Here is the same math run on three spending profiles. Groceries, streaming, gas, and everything else, with the annual fee subtracted.

ProfileAnnual spendAmex netGold Card netWinner
Broad spender$20,400$475$562Gold, by $87
Grocery and gas heavy$12,200$447$316Amex, by $131
Low spend$7,200$160$166Gold, by $6

The broad spender puts $6,000 at supermarkets, $600 on streaming, $1,800 on gas, and $12,000 elsewhere. The Amex earns $360 plus $36 plus $54 plus $120, which is $570, minus the $95 fee. The Gold Card earns 3% of $20,400, which is $612, minus $50.

The grocery and gas household puts $6,000 at supermarkets, $1,200 on streaming, $3,000 on gas, and $2,000 elsewhere. The Amex's bonus categories now cover most of the spend.

The rule that falls out of this: the Amex wins when the 6% and 3% categories are a large share of your spending. Once non-bonus spending clears roughly $7,650 a year with the grocery cap maxed, the Gold Card's flat 3% takes over.

The Disney Credit Changes the Fee

The Amex carries a $120 annual Disney streaming credit: up to $10 a month back on a subscription purchase at DisneyPlus.com, Hulu.com, or Stream.ESPN.com. If you already pay for a Disney bundle, that credit is a rebate on money you were spending anyway, and it is larger than the $95 annual fee.

That makes the Amex's effective cost negative $25 a year, against $50 for the Gold Card. A $75 swing, and it moves the crossover point from about $7,650 of non-bonus spending to about $13,650.

ProfileAmex net with Disney creditGold Card netWinner
Broad spender$595$562Amex, by $33
Grocery and gas heavy$567$316Amex, by $251
Low spend$280$166Amex, by $114

If you subscribe to a Disney bundle, the Amex wins all three profiles. If you do not, it wins one of three. That is a strange thing for a rewards comparison to hinge on, and it is the honest answer.

The Redemption Difference

The Gold Card's cash back can only go into a Robinhood brokerage account, at 1 cent per point. The Amex pays Reward Dollars you can take as a statement credit, deposit into an Amex savings account, or spend at Amazon checkout. Both charge a foreign transaction fee, 2.7% and 3%, so neither belongs abroad.