I graduated in 2016 with $47,000 in student loans. I'm 31 now, working as a product manager in Denver making $118K. I've been maxing my 401(k) since 2022, I have a side hustle doing UX consulting that nets me about $1,200/month, and I finally have money left over after expenses to invest.

But I'm overwhelmed by brokerage choices. So I opened accounts at both Robinhood and E*TRADE in 2024 and spent six months actually using both. Here's what I found.

The Fee Comparison That Actually Matters

Both platforms offer $0 commission on stock and ETF trades. That's table stakes in 2025. Where they diverge:

FeeRobinhoodE*TRADE
Stock/ETF commission$0$0
Options contract fee$0 ($0.35 Gold)$0.65 ($0.50 after 30 trades/qtr)
Futures contract fee$0.75$1.50
Margin rate (under $25K)5.75%12.95%
Account minimum$0$0
Mutual fundsN/A$0 for no-load; $19.99 for transaction-fee
Margin rate under $25K in the account

E*TRADE charges more than double Robinhood's margin rate. On a $10,000 margin balance held a year, that gap is roughly $720 in extra interest, larger than most of the commission differences these comparisons usually focus on.

Robinhood5.75%
E*TRADE12.95%
Data table
ItemValueShare
Robinhood5.75%30.7%
E*TRADE12.95%69.3%

That margin rate difference is brutal. On a $10,000 margin balance for a year, Robinhood charges $575. E*TRADE charges $1,295. That's a $720 difference on a single year of moderate margin use.

What Each Platform Actually Offers

Robinhood is a trading-first app. You open it, tap buy, done in three seconds. It supports stocks, ETFs, options, crypto, fractional shares from $1, 24/7 crypto trading, recurring investments, and a cash card with stock rewards. No mutual funds or bonds.

ETRADE* is a full-service broker. You get stocks, ETFs, options, futures, 4,000+ mutual funds, bonds, and CDs. Three platform tiers from standard to ETRADE Pro. Pre-built managed portfolios starting at $500. Extensive research tools. No crypto.

The trade-off is clear: Robinhood is simpler and cheaper. E*TRADE is more comprehensive but costs more for options traders and margin users.

My Experience Using Both

I put $5,000 into each account in January 2025. On Robinhood, I set up recurring investments of $200/month into VOO and $100/month into individual tech stocks. I've done maybe 12 trades total. The interface is clean and fast. I don't miss mutual funds at my stage. I'm 34 with a long time horizon and 100% equity allocation.

On E*TRADE, I opened a Roth IRA and rolled over an old 401(k). The rollover took two weeks and was painless. I used their pre-built "Core" portfolio with a 70/30 split. The research tools are genuinely impressive, but I log in maybe once a quarter.

The Student Loan Angle

Here's what most comparisons miss: your student loan situation should influence your brokerage choice.

If you're still paying off loans, prioritize tax-advantaged accounts before taxable investing. Both platforms offer IRAs. Robinhood gives a 1% IRA match (3% with Gold). E*TRADE doesn't offer an IRA match.

If you have private loans at 7%+, paying those down aggressively beats investing in a taxable brokerage. The guaranteed return of eliminating 7% debt beats expected market returns.

Which Should You Choose?

Pick Robinhood if: You want the simplest experience, are building your first portfolio with small amounts, trade options occasionally, or want crypto in the same app.

Pick ETRADE if:** You want mutual funds and bonds, are rolling over a 401(k), are an active options trader doing 30+ trades per quarter, or want pre-built managed portfolios.

Use both if: You want the best of both worlds. Robinhood for active trading and small-dollar investing. E*TRADE for retirement and managed portfolios.

The Bottom Line

For millennials early in their careers, Robinhood wins on simplicity and cost. The $0 options fees alone save hundreds per year. The 5.75% margin rate is industry-leading.

But if you're rolling over a 401(k) or want mutual funds, E*TRADE is the better home. Don't overthink it. Pick one, start investing, and adjust as your life changes.