I won $2.3 million in the Powerball in March 2025. I'm a 42-year-old electrician from Ohio who suddenly had more money than I knew what to do with. The first thing I did was panic. The second thing I did was download three investing apps.

If you're in a similar position (sudden wealth, no idea where to start), this comparison is for you. I'm not going to talk about portfolio theory. I'm going to talk about which platform helps you sleep at night, which has fewer fees, and which is less likely to let you make a terrible mistake.

The First Thing You Should Do

  1. Don't invest the lump sum all at once: put it in a high-yield savings account first
  2. Pay off high-interest debt: anything above 7%
  3. Hire a fee-only financial advisor: not someone who earns commissions
  4. Set aside money for taxes: the IRS will take a big chunk
  5. Take your time: you don't need to invest anything for at least 6 months

Account Minimums

For a lottery winner, $20 is nothing. But Robinhood's $0 minimum is more accessible if you're starting small.

Investment Options

Robinhood: Stocks, ETFs, options, futures, crypto (22+ coins), closed-end funds [second_party]

Public.com: Stocks, ETFs, options, crypto (40+ coins), US Treasuries, bonds [second_party]

Key differences: - Futures: Robinhood offers them; Public.com doesn't. Futures are complex and risky. You probably don't need them. [second_party] - Bonds: Public.com offers a Bond Account with 5%+ target yield and $1,000 minimum, a genuine advantage for stable income. [second_party] - Crypto: Public.com lists ~40 coins vs. Robinhood's 22. [second_party]

Fees

Fee TypeRobinhoodPublic.com
Stock/ETF trades$0$0
Options$0 (single-leg)$0.35/contract (multi-leg)
Crypto spread~0.5%1.25%
IRA closure fee$0$150
ACATS transfer out$100$100
Inactivity fee$0$3.99/mo (under $70, inactive 6+ mo)

[second_party] [third_party]

The inactivity fee matters most. Public.com charges $3.99/month if your account is under $70 and inactive for 6+ months. Robinhood has no inactivity fee.

The crypto spread is also important. On a $100,000 Bitcoin purchase, Robinhood's 0.5% spread costs $500. Public.com's 1.25% costs $1,250, a $750 difference. [third_party]

Cash Management

Robinhood: With Gold ($50/year), earn 3.6% APY on eligible brokerage cash, no cap, no minimum. Without Gold, cash earns nothing. [first_party]

Public.com: Earns 3.3% APY on uninvested cash with no minimums, no fees, no membership required. [second_party]

For a lottery winner with $1 million in cash: - Robinhood with Gold: $36,000/year (minus $50 = $35,950 net) - Public.com: $33,000/year (no fees)

Robinhood wins if you pay for Gold. Public.com wins if you want simplicity.

IRA and Retirement

Robinhood: Traditional and Roth IRAs with 1% match (3% with Gold). Maxing your 2026 IRA at $7,500 gets you $75 (standard) or $225 (Gold). [first_party]

Public.com: 1% IRA contribution match but no 3% tier. [second_party]

If you just won $2.3 million, you may not need an IRA. But if you're still working and want to shelter income from taxes, both platforms work.

Margin Rates

As a lottery winner, you should not trade on margin. But if you do, Robinhood has a slight edge.

Mobile App

Public.com has a higher rating but fewer tools. For simplicity, Public.com wins. For analysis, Robinhood wins.

The Lottery Winner's Decision Framework

Choose Robinhood if: - You want 3.6% APY on cash with Gold - You want more trading tools and indicators - You want no inactivity fee - You want a 3% IRA match with Gold

Choose Public.com if: - You want a Bond Account for stable income - You want more crypto options - You want 3.3% APY on cash with no subscription - You prefer a simpler, cleaner interface

What I Actually Did

I split my money. $500,000 in a high-yield savings account at a credit union (4.5% APY). $300,000 in Robinhood with Gold, earning 3.6% APY on cash while I figured out my next move. $200,000 in a Public.com Bond Account for stable income. The rest went to a fee-only financial advisor.

I didn't choose one platform over the other. I used both for different purposes.